Past mortgage remedies can impact future loans

This post originally appeared May 7, 2015 on as “How mortgage settlements affect your score (and for how long)

By Barry Paperno

Dear Speaking of Credit,
Is it possible to have a deed in lieu removed from a credit report after three years? — Alonzo

Dear Alonzo,
As a result of the Great Recession of 2007-09, many homeowners lost their homes to foreclosure or one of the alternatives to foreclosure, such as deed in lieu of foreclosure, short sale, loan modification or other tools for getting out from under a no-longer-affordable mortgage. And as with any situation in which a lender takes a loss on a loan, these consumers have paid an additional cost in the form of derogatory credit.

Now with the passage of time and an improved economy, the homeownership itch has returned for many of these former homeowners, but this time with an additional concern: What to do about the derogatory credit still remaining from those bleak times?

I don’t blame you for asking if it’s possible to have the deed in lieu removed from your credit report, as no doubt you’re ready to move on and wouldn’t it be nice if that black mark could simply be eliminated? Unfortunately, the reality is that the only legitimate way to get an accurately reported foreclosure, deed in lieu, short sale (typically reported as “settled for less than full balance”) or other negative notation removed from your credit report is for the lender reporting it to instruct the credit bureau to strike it from your credit report as a “goodwill” gesture; not something that often happens. Negative but accurate information stays on your report seven years; you have four to go.

So, with removal of the deed in lieu not an option, let’s look instead at the possibility of obtaining a new mortgage while this negative settlement item remains on your credit report for the remaining four years. But first, let’s be sure we have a clear understanding of what we mean by foreclosure and the terms describing its alternatives:

  • Foreclosure: The result of a mortgage going into default, after which the property is sold by the mortgage lender to satisfy the debt.
  • Deed in lieu: A process whereby the homeowner can avoid foreclosure by voluntarily turning the property over to the mortgage lender in return for being released from all obligations under the mortgage.
  • Short sale: The lender agrees to accept a payoff of less than the principal balance when the “underwater” home cannot be sold at price sufficient to pay off the remaining mortgage debt.
  • Loan modification: The mortgage terms are revised to reduce the monthly payments by lowering the interest rate or extending the term of the loan.

If you have been rebuilding your credit by managing your finances responsibly in the years since the deed in lieu, you have good reason to be optimistic about the possibility of a home purchase in the near future, once:

  • Your credit score reaches the lender’s requirement — typically above 700 — which is achievable with stellar payment history and low credit card debt since the deed in lieu first appeared on your credit report.
  • Your current income and other application information meet the lender’s borrowing criteria, such as debt-to-income ratio, length of employment, etc.
  • The necessary waiting period has elapsed for consumers with a deed in lieu in their past.

To better grasp some of the negative credit scoring impacts consumers in these situations have had to overcome and some of what you can expect going forward on your way to renewed homeownership, we’ll take a look at foreclosure and its alternatives in terms of estimated initial score drop, expected length of time for the score to rebound and the various waiting periods for a new conventional mortgage:

Settlements, credit score impact, a new mortgage
Type of settlement Effect on FICO Expected length of time for score rebound Waiting period before getting another conventional mortgage
Foreclosure Can lower a score as much as 160 points Impact lessens over time to where a spotless post-foreclosure credit history and low debt level can deliver a score in the 700+ score range within about 4-5 years. 7 years (2 years with extenuating circumstances)
Deed in lieu or short sale Can lower score as much as 125 points A good mortgage-qualifying score is possible after roughly 3-4 years of timely payments and low debt. 4 years (2 years with extenuating circumstances)
Loan modification Doesn’t affect score as long as payments are made on time Not necessary, as long as payments are made consistently on time after the modification Left up to the lender. Usually 1-4 years

What all of this can mean for you is that, despite the deed in lieu remaining on your credit report, once you manage to rebuild your credit score to above 700, meet the waiting period and mortgage application requirements, and, of course, have some cash to put down, you could find yourself obtaining a new mortgage within the next year or so, if not sooner.

Have a question or comment? 

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s